SelectQuote Review: 5 Things to Know Before You Get a Quote

SelectQuote Review: 5 Things to Know Before You Get a Quote

SelectQuote is one of the oldest players in the sale of insurance direct to consumers. Established in 1985, this company works with a variety of highly ranked insurance carriers and says its goal is to "remove barriers to shopping for insurance."

However, that was not my experience when shopping for insurance with SelectQuote!

Content Continues Below

Here’s What You Need to Know About SelectQuote

As an independent agency, SelectQuote is not a captive of any one company. When you shop with them, you’re getting access to a wide range of quotes from top insurers. But there’s one big problem with the shopping experience that makes the service that SelectQuote offers feel very outdated.

In this article, we’ll take a look at how SelectQuote works, what companies you can get quotes from, how the price quotes stack up and more.

Table of Contents

1. How Does SelectQuote Work?

Using SelectQuote starts with entering some basic info about yourself. For the purposes of this SelectQuote review, I’ll show you what you need to shop for both term life and auto/home insurance quotes.

Term Life Shopping

Like many other insurance shopping sites, SelectQuote says it makes shopping for term life insurance easy. But the reality of actually getting a quote is anything but.

That said, here’s what you need to provide to get started:

  • Your ZIP code
  • Gender
  • Birth date
  • Height
  • Weight

After entering that basic preliminary info, you’re asked to select a coverage amount (Up to $5 million) and a term (10, 15, 20, 30 years).

Money expert Clark Howard has a rule of thumb based on your salary and your age to help you decide how much life insurance is right for you. See his formula here.

Meanwhile, if you're uncertain, you can call the company for free advice at 1-855-653-6700.

The next step is to answer some questions about your personal lifestyle and health:

  • Do you use tobacco?
  • Any driving violations in the past five years?
  • Do you engage in risky activities like piloting aircraft, bungee jumping, hang gliding, mountain and rock climbing, scuba diving, or sky diving?
  • What condition(s) do you have? (Alcohol abuse, depression, high cholesterol, etc.)
  • Is there a family history of heart disease, cancer, stroke or diabetes?

Once you’ve entered all the info above, you expect to get a quote, right?

But what you're really doing when you click the "FINISH" button is submitting a request for a quote.

As I read the fine print, I also noticed I was giving permission to four entities — SelectQuote, Inside Response, Allied Insurance Partners and LiveOps, Inc., — to call me "using an automatic dialing system and pre-recorded and artificial voice messages any time…to market our products and services to you and for all other purposes."

I'm not a fan of robocalls — in fact, I've written about how to stop them. So I wasn't happy with this stipulation.

As an alternative, shoppers do have the option to get a life insurance quote over the phone from SelectQuote by calling that 1-855-653-6700 number.

But the bottom line is this: The info you give to SelectQuote is considered a quote request. You’ll receive a call from an agent in order to actually get your quote.

Auto/Home Insurance Shopping

The process of trying to get a quote for home, auto or an insurance bundle is similarly frustrating.

Here’s what you need to provide to get started:

  • Highest level of education
  • Employment status
  • Do you own or rent your home?
  • Is it your primary residence?
  • Have you filed any home or property claims in the past 5 years?
  • How many vehicles do you want to insure today?
  • Have you had any car accidents, claims or tickets in the past 5 years?

Finally, you enter your name, phone and email. But beware, you’re again consenting to let SelectQuote and others call you any time they want for marketing purposes.

Once again, you can get a quote for home/auto without giving that consent by calling 1-855-226-1289 to speak with a live agent. I opted for the online process instead, to replicate the way most shoppers would get quotes.

The most disappointing part of all was the seven “quotes” I was given online. Only two were from actual insurance companies — Progressive and Liberty Mutual.

The other five were links to different insurance lead generation engines: QuoteWizard, AgileRates, QuotesMatch, Insurify and Home Insurance Connect.

But the frustration didn’t end there. When clicking through on the links to my real “quotes” from Progressive and Liberty Mutual, I was just redirected to each insurer’s home page to start the quote process over from scratch!

So I entered all that information for nothing. Very disappointing.

2. What Kinds of Insurance Can You Get Quotes For?

Unlike some of its online competitors that really branch out, SelectQuote keeps it simple with just a handful of lines of insurance:

  • Life
  • Auto
  • Home
  • Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage

We’ve already mentioned life, home and auto in this review. But SelectQuote says it works with Aetna, Cigna, Humana, Mutual of Omaha and UnitedHealthcare on the Medicare lines.

3. Where Is SelectQuote Available?

SelectQuote is licensed to offer all insurance products in all 50 U.S. states and Washington, D.C. However, SelectQuote does not sell life insurance in South Dakota.

You can find state licensing info here.

4. Which Insurance Companies Work With SelectQuote?

SelectQuote works with a variety of companies depending on the kind of insurance you’re getting a quote for.

Term Life Insurance

For term life insurance, SelectQuote can quote you with almost a dozen companies:

  • AIG
  • Banner Life
  • Companion
  • Globe Life
  • Lincoln
  • Pacific Life
  • Protective
  • Prudential
  • SBLI
  • United of Omaha
  • William Penn

Auto and Home Insurance

When it comes to auto and home insurance, the company has relationships with the following nearly two dozen carriers:

  • American Modern
  • American Strategic
  • Dairyland
  • Encompass
  • Foremost
  • GeoVera
  • Hartford
  • Hippo
  • Kemper
  • Liberty Mutual
  • Lighthouse
  • Mercury
  • MetLife
  • National General
  • Nationwide
  • Plymouth Rock
  • Progressive
  • Safeco
  • Stillwater
  • Travelers
  • UPC
  • Velocity Risk

5. How Are the Prices on SelectQuote?

When it comes to buying life insurance, there are two things you need to pay attention to: Price and a carrier’s financial stability rating.

I shopped with SelectQuote on a couple of different term life insurance options.

First, I got a quote for a 20-year term life policy for myself in the amount of $250,000:

Carrier Monthly Premium
Pacific Life $27.10
Lincoln National $28.64
SBLI $32.55

I followed that up with a quote for double the coverage — $500,000 — for 20 years:

Carrier Monthly Premium
Pacific Life $47.70
Lincoln National $50.23
SBLI $58.46

As a reminder, to obtain both quotes, I had to speak with an agent on the phone and answer a battery of questions based on my initial responses on the website. That process was very cumbersome.

Now, just a quick word about the financial stability of the insurers I was quoted with. Both Pacific Life and Lincoln National are rated A+ by A.M. Best, the leading credit rating agency for the insurance world. SBLI, meanwhile, is rated A.

Clark Howard recommends that you only buy life insurance from companies that are rated A++ or A+ by A.M. Best.

By looking at an insurer’s balance sheet, financial strength rating, long-term issuer credit rating and other data points, A.M. Best is able to give the best educated guess in the industry about a particular company’s future ability to pay claims when you need them.

That’s what the letter grades reflect, with A++ being the absolute highest and A+ just one notch below.

Final Thought

SelectQuote does not make getting a quote for life insurance easy. Out of all the online life insurance sellers I've reviewed — including Policygenius, Bestow and Haven Life, among others — SelectQuote is my least favorite.

Having to get on the phone with an agent is time-consuming and an annoyance in an age when we’re all used to digital shopping making our lives easier — not more difficult.

By contrast, those three competitors I mentioned all offer easy online quotes for term life insurance with no medical exam, something that SelectQuote does not offer. They give you instant quotes online, not over the phone.

Meanwhile, we've got a lot more guidance on how to shop for the insurance that matters to your life. Be sure to check out our list of the Best and Worst Auto Insurers, Best and Worst Home Insurers and our piece on How to Buy Term Life Insurance.

More Insurance Stories on Clark.com: